Tuesday 28 January 2014

Compulsory Voting?? Bad Idea


It’s been a while since I last made a post and maybe some of my readers are wondering why is it that the Jamaican Tory seems to have fallen off the grid, well the fact is that I’m back now and ready to issue the first post of 2013, which also happens to be the 50th post in this Jamaican Tory series . So many things have taken place in my absence, so many incidents I can write on but for now I’ll choose something very close to home.
It concerns some rather controversial comments made by a prominent member of parliament Everald Warmington from South West St Catherine, a rather eccentric character known for his wit and flamboyant style but is who also a true conservative and one of the few members of the present parliament who has spoken up in support of the monarchy and it’s place in our constitution, coming in confrontation with certain members of the political left in order to get his point across. A man some (particularly the left) would consider to be highhanded, obnoxious and even downright rude but whom I  have come to have respect for due to his conservative views and uncompromising stance even if his style of doing so is a bit unorthodox, he seems to have his head on straight, which is why it gives me no great pleasure to have to criticize him now.

                                

In a speech made to a group of party supporters, he was reported to have said that "If you don't vote, you don't count," basically telling his constituents that those who refuse to exercise their constitutional right to vote, should not expect to receive any forms of aid from his constituency office. Naturally these comments sent shock waves across the island, although it is common knowledge that politicians are hardly the most respected people in Jamaica, few would dream that an MP would be brazen enough to make such a statement on national television (in truth a number of politicians have already adopting this practice of having little dealings or contacts with those who are no aligned to them or their party, even though they publicly deny it). Everyone from the media to various civil society groups wasted no time in villanising Warmington for his comments and to be frank I can’t say I’m shocked and I doubt he is either, it’s not the first time he’s been on the receiving end of such angry public backlash for what is considered to be extremely offensive language which some even goes as far as to say displays his contempt for the people that he is sworn to serve as member of parliament.
However when the dust settles and all the trash talk is over, Warmington’s comments does leave room for the nation to debate a very important issue, should compulsory voting be imposed in Jamaica or not?, some countries already have this e.g. Australia, Argentina, Singapore, Peru and a few others, it’s not a whole lot but still there is precedent for it.

                                                    
                                     

This year 2014, will mark the 70th anniversary that universal adult suffrage was granted in this country and anyone aware of our history will know perfectly well the hard struggles that our ancestors had to go through in order to obtain the right to elect their representatives in free and fair elections, a right which they finally won on October 27, 1944 when His Majesty King George VI gave his royal assent to the new constitution. This Order in Council saw  the hosting of the first democratic elections in on December 12 of that same year where every adult subject of the Crown in Jamaica was entitled to a vote. In his tirade Warmington charged that those who refuse to vote are in fact refusing to take any interest in the affairs of the nation and as such should not be entitled to any form of benefits for their lack of participation, he also called their actions as being disrespectful to those who gave their blood, sweat and tears to earn a right that many people now take for granted .

                                            


While I do sympathize with Warmington’s point of view, I can hardly say that I agree,  the truth  is that, while his comments may have triggered the calls for a discussion on compulsory voting, I seriously doubt it will go past the discussion change. If the history of Jamaica is anything to go by then it’s safe to say, the people will never accept such an imposition from the government but at the same time nor will they stand for any government that seeks to deny them the right of this franchise, Jamaicans love their freedom of choice it's just who we are as a people, in fact the latest Freedom in the world index ranks Jamaica and its Caribbean Commonwealth partners rather highly on the freedom index, far above any other group of nations in the developing world and that’s saying something.  People nowadays are getting rather disillusioned with the whole political process and comments like those uttered by Mr. Warmington only serves to heighten the cynicism among an already disgruntled population, a call for compulsory voting at this time is most certainly not a good idea, The Jamaican People simple will not stand for it.